The importance of precision in lease agreements: A cautionary tale

In the realm of retail leasing, precision in lease agreements is paramount. A recent case serves as a stark reminder of the potential pitfalls when details are overlooked or incorrectly documented. This case involved the lease of part of a property described as a “lock-up shop”, but an error in the address led to significant complications for the lessee and subsequent owners.

The case overview

The lessee, operating under the belief that their lease included additional land at the rear of the property, used this area for parking vehicles and installed storage sheds. This rear section, accessible via a rear lane, was integral to their operations. However, the lease agreement contained an incorrect address and referred to part of the property’s land, creating ambiguity about the agreed leased area, called the demised area. Additionally, the disclosure statement inaccurately indicated that no vehicle parking was included in the leased area.

Complications arise

When the property was sold, the new owners reviewed the lease and disclosure statement and found discrepancies. They decided that the lessee did not have the right to park their vehicles or use the back area and demanded the removal of the sheds, even though they had been on site for several years. This decision was based on the lease documentation, which failed to explicitly include the rear area as part of the demised premises.

Lessons learned

This situation highlights several crucial aspects of lease agreements that both lessors and owners must meticulously address:

  1. Accurate description of the agreed area: The lease must contain a precise and accurate description of the demised premises. Any ambiguity can lead to disputes and potentially significant financial losses, underscoring the importance of precision in lease agreements.
  2. Clear floor plan: A detailed floor plan should accompany the lease, clearly marking the boundaries of the agreed area. This visual aid is not just a formality but a crucial tool that can help prevent misunderstandings and ensure both parties have a mutual understanding of the leased space.
  3. Licenced areas: Any separately licenced areas, such as parking spaces or storage areas, should be explicitly included in the lease. This is not just a detail but a necessary step to ensure thoroughness and avoid future conflicts.
  4. Disclosure statements: The disclosure statement must include accurate information and reflect the actual lease terms. Misstatements or omissions can lead to disputes and legal challenges.

The fundamental error in this case underscores the critical importance of precision and clarity in lease agreements. For lessees, ensuring that the lease accurately reflects their understanding of the demised premises is crucial. For lessors, providing detailed and unambiguous lease documents is essential to avoid disputes and maintain good tenant relationships. This case serves as a cautionary tale for all involved in retail leasing to diligently review and confirm the specifics of their lease agreements.

Learn more about LeaseInfo by visiting our About Us or book a demo to see how it can help you today.